Re: Filtering argument lists (e.g. for grep)

["Nikolay Aleksandrovich Pavlov (ZyX)" <kp-pav@xxxxxxxxx>]

07.12.2015, 15:18, "Nikolay Aleksandrovich Pavlov (ZyX)" <kp-pav@xxxxxxxxx>:
>  07.12.2015, 15:03, "Nikolay Aleksandrovich Pavlov (ZyX)" <kp-pav@xxxxxxxxx>:
>>   07.12.2015, 14:51, "Dominik Vogt" <vogt@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>:
>>>    On Mon, Dec 07, 2015 at 11:23:54AM +0000, Peter Stephenson wrote:
>>>>     On Mon, 7 Dec 2015 11:56:22 +0100
>>>>     Dominik Vogt <vogt@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
>>>>     > Maybe grep is a bad example because this can be done with the
>>>>     > --exclude= option. But could zsh help filtering the names
>>>>     > generated by globbing in a more general way so that I could write
>>>>     >
>>>>     > $ <foo> *
>>>>     >
>>>>     > and have zsh automagically filter the results of the * (not
>>>>     > everywhere; only for commands that have this feature enabled) so
>>>>     > that the non-matching names are not passed to the command in the
>>>>     > first place?
>>>
>>>>     You could use a global alias, e.g.
>>>>
>>>>     alias -g '@*'='*~(*\~|\#*|ChangeLog)'
>>>
>>>    Yes, but then I'd need an alias for every potential pattern, e.g.
>>>    @*.s*, @**/*, @*.c.* etc.
>>>
>>>>     Ig you want that first * to be something more flexible you can use a
>>>>     glob qualifier.
>>>>
>>>>       gi () {
>>>>         [[ $REPLY != (*\~|\#*|ChangeLog) ]]
>>>>       }
>>>>
>>>>     and use
>>>>
>>>>       <foo> *(+gi)
>>>
>>>    That sounds good, but is there a way to make that qualifier a
>>>    default for certain commands? As an alternative, is it possible
>>>    to access the command name from inside the qualifier function?
>>>
>>>      function gi () {
>>>        if <command should be filtered>; then
>>>          [[ $REPLY != (*\~|\#*|ChangeLog) ]]
>>>        fi
>>>      }
>>
>>   And there is another possibility: considering you want to do this thing with command `foo` you need to do the following:
>>
>>   1. Create an alias `foo='noglob foo'`.
>>   2. Create a function `foo` like this:
>>
>>           function foo()
>>           {
>>               local -a args=( "${@[@]}" )
>>               local -a new_args
>>               for (( I=2; I<= $#args; I++ )) ; do
>>                   if [[ $args[I] != ${${args[I]}//[*?]} ]] ; then # If argument contains glob pattern
>>                       args[I]+="(+gi)"
>>                       new_args=( $~args[I] )
>>                       args[I,I]=( $new_args )
>>                       (( I += #new_args - 1 ))
>>                   fi
>>               done
>>               command foo "${args[@]}"
>>           }
>>
>>       . I.e. in place of leaving zsh to expand globs, expand it in your function “manually”, with necessary additions.
>
>  Though this variant is for one command. For multiple you need some adjustments:
>
>  1. `alias foo='noglob filterglob foo'`
>  2. Function is `filterglob`, starts with `local -r cmd="$1"; shift`, ends with `command "$cmd" "${args[@]}"`.
>
>  And I should not have used `I=2` (it initially meant to skip command) in any case, replace `I=2` with `I=1`.

I have checked and the following filterglob function works:

    filterglob () {
    	local -r cmd="$1" 
    	shift
    	local -a args=("${@[@]}") 
    	local -a new_args
    	for ((I=1; I<=$#args; I++ )) do
    		if [[ $args[I] != ${${args[I]}/[*?]} ]]
    		then
    			args[I]+="~*.png" 
    			new_args=($~args[I]) 
    			args[I,I]=("${new_args[@]}") 
    			(( I += #new_args - 1 ))
    		fi
    	done
    	"$cmd" "${args[@]}"
    }

. But there is one downside: you need additional code to handle CSH_NULL_GLOB, NULL_GLOB and NOMATCH options. There are the following combinations:

1. nonomatch, nocshnullglob, nonullglob: leave pattern as-is. Requires 1. adding (N) at the end of the pattern 2. reverting args[I] change. (Note: *.c literally is also possible file name, so you can’t just “check if #new_args == 1 and new_args[1] == args[I] and if yes revert”, (N) is needed.)
2. cshnullglob, nonullglob: if there are no matches, leave no arguments, but if all patterns on the command-line have no matches, error out. Requires 1. adding (N) (or it will error out when processing new_args) 2. saving 1 if there were expanded globs.
3. nullglob: should work as-is, including when variant with (N) is used.
4. nomatch: should also work as-is, but when (N) is used requires additionally explicitly errorring out.

The final function works something like this:

    filterglob () {
        local -r cmd="$1"
        shift
        local -a args
        args=( "${@[@]}" )
        local -a new_args
        local -i expandedglobs=0
        local first_unexpanded_glob=
        for ((I=1; I<=$#args; I++ )) do
            if [[ $args[I] != ${${args[I]}/[*?]} ]]
            then
                local initial_arg=${args[I]}
                args[I]+="~*.png(N)"
                new_args=( $~args[I] )
                if (( $#new_args )) ; then
                    expandedglobs=1
                else
                    if [[ $options[cshnullglob] == off
                          && $options[nullglob] == off ]] ; then
                        if [[ $options[nomatch] == on ]] ; then
                            : ${~${args[I]%\(N\)}}  # Will error out.
                        else
                            new_args=( "$initial_arg" )
                        fi
                    fi
                    if [[ -z $first_unexpanded_glob ]] ; then
                        first_unexpanded_glob=${args[I]%\(N\)}
                        readonly first_unexpanded_glob
                    fi
                fi
                args[I,I]=( "${new_args[@]}" )
                (( I += $#new_args - 1 ))
            fi
        done
        if [[ $options[cshnullglob] == on && $options[nullglob] == off ]] ; then
            if (( !expandedglob )) ; then
                : $~first_unexpanded_glob  # Will error out.
            fi
        fi
        "$cmd" "${args[@]}"
    }

. Note that this function has no `emulate -L zsh` at the top, so may be broken by some options. Also AFAIK you cannot use this specific function without `setopt extendedglob` and `zmodload zsh/parameter` (for `$options`).

// Do not forget to replace `~*.png` with whatever you need, I used this for testing purposes.


>>>    Ciao
>>>
>>>    Dominik ^_^ ^_^
>>>
>>>    --
>>>
>>>    Dominik Vogt
>>>    IBM Germany